Sheepshead at the OBX

Sheepshead are challenging, fun and excellent table fare

Fishing for sheepshead on the Outer Banks in March is a unique experience that draws anglers looking to catch these elusive, hard-fighting fish. Known for their toothy, human-like mouths, sheepshead are a popular target in the waters off the coast of North Carolina, especially during the cooler months when they move closer to shore to spawn.

March marks the beginning of the prime sheepshead season, as these fish begin to gather around structures like piers, bridges, and wrecks in shallow waters. The temperatures bring these fish closer to shore, making them more accessible to anglers. Local fisherman, Jason McClain, explains that March is often the best time to target sheepshead because the fish are more concentrated around structures and hungry after the winter.

“The key to catching them is making sure you’re using the right bait,” says McClain. “Fiddler crabs are a must, but don’t overlook clams or shrimp. They’re all favorites of sheepshead, and you’ll have the best luck if you get them in front of the fish on the right structure.” McClain notes that sheepshead are notoriously finicky, so patience is essential when fishing for them. Their bite is subtle, and anglers often don’t feel a strong pull like with other fish species. Instead, sheepshead tend to nibble or lightly tug at the bait, which can make it hard to detect when they’re actually biting.

Fishing around the Outer Banks’ piers or near natural reefs is ideal, especially early in the morning or later in the afternoon when the water is calmer and the fish are feeding more actively. Anglers should focus on areas where barnacles and crustaceans are abundant, as sheepshead are known to feed on these organisms. The challenge comes in the form of the fish’s tough mouths, which can make it difficult to hook them properly, even after they bite.

Despite the challenge, sheepshead fishing is rewarding, especially when you feel the familiar tug of a hooked fish. McClain reminds anglers that, while it’s a delicate game, the effort is often well worth it. “Once you hook into a big one, you’ll know it. They fight hard and they fight smart, and that’s what makes them so fun to catch.”

For those willing to spend time and patience, fishing for sheepshead off the Outer Banks in March is well worth the effort.