Watauga County hunter takes down huge ‘passing through’ buck

Chase McLean killed this buck on Thanksgiving afternoon in Watauga County, N.C.

Lever-action rifle with iron sights makes quick work of 162-inch, 11-point mountain buck

Just passing through.

That’s what Chase McLean of Boone, N.C., thought about the 162-inch, 11-point buck he killed on Thanksgiving afternoon.

He’d never seen the huge buck before, never gotten a trail-camera photo of it on the property he was hunting in the mountains of Watauga County, tucked in the northwestern corner of North Carolina, hard by Tennessee and Virginia.

And when the buck passed his pop-up ground blind at 35 yards, it wasn’t wasting any time or hanging around — nose to the ground, mouth open, panting, chasing a doe.

“He had to just be passing through,” McLean said.

But the morning after he killed the buck — which carried a typical 5×6 rack with main beams almost 25 inches long, an 18 1/4-inch inside spread and tines measuring 10 1/2, 10 1/8, 9 and 8 3/4 inches — when he was skinning it, he found out that his uncle had an enormous shed antler from 2017, found in a Christmas tree patch about five miles away. Once he saw the shed, there was no question it came from the huge buck he killed with a lever-action Marlin .45-70 rifle with iron sights.
Dixie RV

“There is no question it came from the same deer,” he said. “The shed was his right-side antler, and it’s identical to his right-side antler.

Chase McLean killed this buck on Thanksgiving afternoon in Watauga County, N.C.

“It’s been a blessing and a curse,” said McLean, 28, who works for AT&T but guides turkey hunters, wild-hog hunters and trout fishermen on the side. “Where am I ever going to find another buck like this; they don’t grow them like that around here.”

It was 5:10 on Thanksgiving afternoon when McLean saw a doe trotting through the woods, along a well-worn deer trail he had set up to watch. The buck was 20 yards behind, matching the doe step for step.

“I saw him, and I knew he was big, but I didn’t have much time,” he said.

At 35 yards, a quick shot high in the shoulder put the buck down on the spot.

“I got out of my blind, went and got my dad and brought him back, and he couldn’t believe it,” McLean said. “My dad, when I was about 12, he told me, if you can put a buck’s rack in a 5-gallon bucket, you need to let him walk. This was the first buck I’ve shot in five years.”

McLean never hung the buck from a set of scales but said it was easily heavier than 200 pounds — but maybe not the biggest animal he’s killed from his ground blind this season.

“I shot a bear from the same blind on Nov. 5,” he said. “It came in from behind and stuck its head in one of the windows. I’ve had more bears than deer on my trail cameras. They love me; I must smell like a honey bun.

“I have two different spots I hunt, and there’s been more action this year around that blind. I’ve only hunted the other stand a couple of times.”

The deer was the first that McLean has shot with his .45-70, a rifle he fell in love with after his father, Tracy McLean, bought one two years ago.

“I played around with his and shot it some, and I loved it, so I got one,” he said. “I didn’t want to put a scope on it, just iron sights. It’s a whole lot of gun for deer, but it works.”

About Dan Kibler 887 Articles
Dan Kibler is the former managing editor of Carolina Sportsman Magazine. If every fish were a redfish and every big-game animal a wild turkey, he wouldn’t ever complain. His writing and photography skills have earned him numerous awards throughout his career.